This is an article I wrote in 2003. Thirteen years later, the debate is still raging! Original article can be found here.
There can be little doubt that the defined benefit pension scheme business is going through a bad time, with UK and Irish pension schemes still underperforming. To address this problem, going forward, pension schemes and their sponsors should establish a platform to understand, monitor and control their short-term exposure to both the assets and the liabilities
Did they see it coming? - For the most part, no. While both pension schemes and insurance companies were well aware that the crashing equity markets of 2002 were sending their principal assets into free-fall, there was little they could do but fervently pray for a recovery, and in part those prayers have been answered. Equities are slowly consolidating and fears of a global crash have receded. However while the pain has eased, the recovery in the equities market has been fairly moderate and reli ...
28 June 2005 – Market Diary
Avid readers of this column will know that ten days ago, with the real yield at a June ‘05 high of 1.56%, we drew a trend line and tentatively predicted that those levels wouldn’t last.
It’s not that the market believes the 2% 2035 index linked gilt is fundamentally too cheap at 120.03; this asset’s price is driven by supply and demand.
The five storey early 1800s Victorian home in Belgravia costs £15m, not because the price of bricks has gone up in Central London, but because the buyers have decided Eaton Squa ...
Redington welcome the PLSA DB Taskforce’s work and focus on the challenges facing DB schemes.
Click to tweet >> Redington welcome @thePLSA DB Taskforce work. Read our thoughts on the DB landscape here: http://bit.ly/2cF10rY via @Redington
We have replied to the Taskforce’s Call for Evidence with our own views and experiences from working with schemes. Below is a summary of the key points from our response.
Schemes face many challenges in a volatile macro environment. Generating the returns and contributions to give members financial security in retirement ...
On Friday, June 24th, Britain voted to leave the European Union. It’s fair to say this surprised a lot of people (on both sides), including the markets. Falling interest rates, a weaker pound and political uncertainty has left a lot of people feeling on edge.
For those of us responsible for managing pension funds, can it be useful to reflect on the “VUCA” of our time.
Volatility, Uncertainty, Complexity and Ambiguity
Derived from the US military and now used in corporate strategy, VUCA is a term used to describe extreme conditions. For those of us in the w ...
The ramifications for investors of the UK’s referendum decision will take some time to materialise.
We are entering uncharted territory - nobody knows precisely how Brexit will be implemented or its consequences.
What is clear is the result will herald a period of considerable uncertainty and market volatility.
If we have learnt anything from history, it is that these kinds of major events happen surprisingly regularly. Which is why it is so important to design and implement a robust, risk-managed and well-diversified investment strategy for the long term. And why it so imp ...
What are the economic implications, potential market impact, and consequences for UK pension schemes of Brexit?
In my previous post, I discussed the timeline for Brexit, should it happen, and split it into three periods: pre-referendum, post-referendum negotiations and post-negotiations.
The purpose of establishing these divisions was to emphasize that leaving the EU would not elicit an immediate step-change for the UK economy. The change would be gradual and the economy would behave differently in each period.
With that in mind, let’s consider (briefly!) the economic impli ...
At Redington we read with great interest the pension regulator’s DB funding statement 2016. I thought the four key takeaways from an investment perspective were:
1. Acknowledge the importance of negative cashflow, and plan for it.
“As schemes mature, liquidity planning is becoming an important consideration, especially where the cash flow requirements represent a significant proportion of the scheme assets. Market developments may mean that schemes are forced to sell assets at lower than expected prices in order to meet cash flow demands. This could put increased pr ...
Automobiles started out as a toy for the rich, a symbol of excess.
They were complex and needed expert drivers. Then, Henry Ford came along and turned it all on its head. The Ford ‘Model T’ was revolutionary for its time - it helped bring cars to the masses and took the mystery out of the ‘horseless-carriage’.
Is the way we look at hedge funds not dissimilar to the infancy of the automobile industry?
Surrounded by mystery, a black box that’s reliant on the magic of manager skill, so-called ‘alpha’. People pay for things they don’ ...
Unless you have been living on Mars for the last few months...
In a cave, with your eyes shut, and your fingers in your ears...
It will have come to your attention that there will soon be a referendum on these shores.
Depending on your political hue, this referendum is one of two things:
An opportunity for the United Kingdom to unshackle itself from an ossified bureaucracy, to protect its borders, and to finally Make Britain Great Again.
A grave threat to the prosperity of the British people, which has been seized upon by political opportunists for personal ...
Alpha describes the excess returns a fund can generate relative to the return of a reference benchmark. This benchmark return is called Beta.
Traditionally, these benchmarks were market cap weighted indices, such as the FTSE All Share or S&P 500. Since the 1970's, it has been possible to buy cheap access to them via passive funds.
Click to tweet >> An increasing number of Smart Beta strategies have tried to improve on the market cap weighted benchmark: http://bit.ly/1Po1gnP
In recent years, an increasing number of Smart Beta strategies have tried to improve on the ...
The landscape for managing pension schemes continues to change..
Now, more than ever, pension trustees and corporate sponsors are facing a number of challenges: lower yields, sponsor balance sheet and new regulations to name a few. However, the fundamental problem still remains the same. To secure and protect member benefits, funding deficits have to be repaired.
In the past, deficit repair discussions have happened in a silo way. Every three years, trustees and sponsor would get together and have what is more of a negotiation over contributions, rather than aim to agree a long- ...
PRS is becoming an area of interest for institutional investors. Why?
First of all, what is it?
Private Rented Sector (PRS) is residential property that is not occupied by the owner but rented out by private (as opposed to social) landlords. The English Housing Survey suggests it currently represents 19% of the English residential market.
According to PIA Property Data Report (2014), the UK Private Rented Sector market is £839bn in size. To put that into context, the UK commercial property market is £683bn.
Why is it interesting for potential investors?
Clients often ask us to what extent our expected returns should adjust to changing market conditions. For an investment grade bond, this is relatively easy - you will earn the credit spread less any defaults. So it’s quite straightforward and objective. For equities, it is much harder to say whether the market is over or under-valued. There are lots of measures that appear to work historically, but interpreting the evidence is fraught with subtleties. One commonly used metric is the Shiller P/E ratio- but does the evidence hold up?
Shiller P/E Ratio
Click to tweet >> T ...
In our previous RedBlog post, my colleague Dan discussed how to incorporate expected rate rises into the liability hedging decision. In this piece I offer an alternative perspective on yields and liability hedging.
A Little Background
Over the last few years, many investors have delayed hedging as they believed that benchmark yields would increase, meaning that hedging would be cheaper later. These increases were expected as a result of the end of quantitative easing and central banks raising their historically low policy rates.
It has been a long wait.
Today, unemployment is c ...
Most pension scheme trustees would agree on one thing. Long-term interest rates are at low levels in the UK today (compared to their history). It’s easy to find explanations for this among economists. It's just as easy to find predictions they will go up, down, or stay the same. Unfortunately economists and markets have a poor track record of predicting interest rate moves.
The point of this post is not to offer another view on interest rates.
If we believe rates are rising should we still be hedging?
Pension schemes feel like they are stuck between a rock and ...
How can the language of music help to decipher the jargon in pensions? Many industries and professionals carry their own technical language (“jargon” for everybody else), so it can be helpful to translate this into more familiar terms.
During her one week internship at Redington, A-level student Antara Roy did just this – read on to see how playing a flute is useful in learning how to prepare a flight plan:
"A passion of mine has always been music; whether it has been listening to ...
“When deciding how to invest a pension fund’s resources you must consider the indexation treatment of each liability tranche to get an accurate picture of the interest rate and inflation sensitivity of scheme liabilities”…
…was definitely not what was going through our heads when first joining Redington. It’s easy to look back just 10 months and laugh at those, frankly, basic questions.
The asset universe is an endless world of complexity. A world full of mystery and confusion.
Even the acronyms themselves were more than enough to deal with, ...
In my last Pensions Expert column, I wrote about the challenge for the new Pensions Minister in balancing short-term political expediency with truly progressive pensions policy.
If we are to achieve long-term sustainable retirement provision, policy needs to be aligned with long-term objectives rather than short-term vote-winning.
There have been calls from some quarters for the new Pensions Minister, Ros Altmann, to consolidate the changes made under Steve Webb and his predecessors and resist radical reform. Yet affordability of pensions is one of the UK’s biggest challenges ...
Because sadly, prioritisation doesn’t always mean doing the easiest thing first…. or the sexiest.
In their quest for performance, amateur cyclists, like a number of Trustees and CIOs, can sometimes focus their attention on the wrong things… in this respect, setting the right investment strategy is not dissimilar to cycling and gives rise to the same pitfalls.
We love to focus on the “sexy” and forget about the basics.
What’s Your Average Amateur Cyclist Got To Do With Investment Strategy?
Take your average enthusiastic amateur cyclist. You ...
The tax paid* on your overseas equity dividends is not usually top of the pile when talking about your investment strategy.
However, the issue is significant. Long-term returns can vary by up to 0.5% p.a between two identical global equity indices due to the differing treatment of dividends*.
30 years to 31.12.2014
Net Dividends Index
Gross Dividends Index
Source: Bloom ...
Negative interest rates don’t seem to make a lot of sense.
People value money now, more than potential money in the future. You need to pay people to deposit their money longer-term.
Think about it...
This means interest rates should always be positive. The lognormal distribution is often used for interest rate moves. This does not allow negative rates1. Besides, if it costs money to lend money, it seems likely that people will stop lending.
That’s the theory; what’s the reality?
Like a great many arguments this is ...
What does last week’s Pension Freedom Day mean for more than just the individual? The media coverage has been largely monochrome in its assessment of economic risk.
What about the big picture?
Opinion of the new policy aside, commentators seem to agree on one thing. ‘The risk’ is of retirees blowing their hard-earned savings in a spending spree and becoming dependent upon state welfare programs for maintenance. The imagined queue of new retirees outside Lamborghini showrooms and Luxury cruise operator offices makes for a compelling news story, after all.
Implementing our investment principles means that it would be useful to measure the complexity of different assets and asset allocations via a complexity ranking.
As complexity increases the average expected return tends to increase but the average fund manager fee also increases.
Increasing complexity can be a way of increasing returns without increasing risk.
Low complexity portfolios may not be the best solution for clients needing high returns.
Two of our investment principles are:
“Investment strategy should be as simple a ...
Opinions expressed on RedBlog and in any corresponding comments are the personal opinions of the original authors, not of Redington Limited. Some of the individuals posting to this site, including any moderators, work for Redington Limited. The content is provided for informational purposes only and is not meant to be an endorsement or representation by Redington Limited or any other party. This site is available to the public. No information you consider confidential should be posted to this site. By posting you agree to be solely responsible for the content of all information you contribute, link to, or otherwise upload to the Website and release Redington Limited from any liability related to your use of the Website. You also grant to Redington Limited a worldwide, perpetual, irrevocable, royalty-free and fully-paid, transferable (including rights to sublicense) right to exercise all copyright, publicity, and moral rights with respect to any original content you provide. The comments are moderated. Comments will appear as soon as they are approved by the moderator.
We are here
2 - 6 Austin Friars House
Phone. +44 (0)20 7250 3331
Subscribe to our regular newsletter here
We always like to hear from you, why not send us a message.